Fox vs. Cablevision TV Blackout Extends to Internet

Editor’s note: This is a guest post by Joseph Pope (Linkedin), who works in Broadcast Media. He previously worked at MTV Networks as a Senior Sales Planning Analyst. He has BS, Information Studies and Technology from Syracuse University, and has a MBA, Finance and Media Management from Fordham University.

Did you catch Fox’s hottest new fall TV drama? If you don’t live in the Northeastern United States, you may have missed it. It wasn’t a new show, but a contract dispute over carriage fees between Fox and their distribution partner Cablevision.

During fruitless contract renewal negotiations in mid-October, News Corporation-owned Fox blacked-out their channels from Cablevision households, affecting 3.5 million homes in Long Island, Brooklyn, New York City, Connecticut and New Jersey. Cablevision risked losing angry consumers who might abandon their service for competitors while Fox had to bear substantial decreases in ratings.

 What makes the current blackout truly unique is that News Corp extended the Cablevision embargo from the TV to the Internet. The goal was to prevent Cablevision subscribers from ‘cutting the cord’ and watching all of their Fox programming for free on Hulu or Hulu, which is partly owned by Fox, staked a neutral position. Blackouts might be fairly common during television contract negotiations (at least in recent years), but restricting access over the Internet is unprecedented.

The Internet blackout was flawed in execution and scrapped after a few hours. Not all Cablevision households were actually barred while some non-Cablevision households were blocked from Hulu and This is partly because some users have Cablevision as their Internet provider, but use another service, such as DirecTV for their television.

Although mobile video is not as ubiquitous as online video, it is another medium that blackout-affected Cablevision users could have used to ‘illicitly’ view Fox programming. Blocking Fox programming from Cablevision subscribers who have wireless carriers like AT&T or T-Mobile in that blackout region is a logistical and technical impossibility. Consumers may not wish to view Fox content over their iphone’s small screen on Hulu or, but perhaps they will on an iPad or Wi-Fi connected netbook.

With an ever expanding world of viewing devices (iPad, SlingBox), content aggregators (Netflix, Hulu), and delivery pipelines (TCP/IP, Wi-Fi, 4G) content providers like Fox will have their hands full keeping their intellectual property under tight control. As the years go by, hard drive memory space will double, Internet bandwidth will increase, video compression technologies will keep file sizes small, and Fox will find it that much harder to maintain control.

For now, Fox may find it advantageous to wield a stick over a carrot during contract negotiations. What Fox will do when consumers have scores of other media consumption options at their disposal remains to be seen.

tag TAGS: , , , ,
Short URL:
b2p Ensure that you follow us on Twitter and Like us on Facebook
Hercules holds a B.Comm Finance from Ryerson University in Toronto, Canada. He is a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) level 3 candidate. He was previously a contributor at FiLife, a finance website owned by Dow Jones and IAC. Write to [email protected]
We are perfectly committed to the highest ethical and professional codes of conduct and standards in the industry on a firm wide basis. Learn more about us, our contributors, and our governance
We encourage you to comment. Comments are moderated. Comments that are abusive, off-topic, have marginal substance, or include promotional content will be removed. We cannot facilitate requests to edit or remove comments, or explain moderation decisions
  • Jesus

    I know that it is a pain to switch TV providers, but I strongly suggest looking into DISH Network. Yes it is an inconvenience to switch, but with DISH you don’t to worry about switching providers again. You don’t have to worry about not having your channels like Fox. Plus right now DISH is offering new customers up to three HD receivers for free. And everyone is welcome to take advantage of the HD free for life promotion to upgrade your channels to HD for no additional cost on your bill. Go to for more info!

Business 2.0 Press publishes exclusive business tech news and analysis covering start-ups to large-caps from Bay & Wall streets since 2008 from a group of highly knowledgeable industry professionals that abide by the toughest industry codes of conduct and professional standards lightMore

lightAdd value by subscribing (RSS)

logo has the most stock ratios for public companies. Get the most comprehensive micro insight on public firms available on the web, all for free.
Stock Fractionsgo


Colon cancer is one of the leading causes of death. Irrespective of family history, everyone is exposed to the risk. About 90% of colon cancer cases begin from non-cancerous tumors, polyps, which could form in the large bowel. Screening with a colonoscopy will painlessly remove any polyps hence almost entirely reducing your risk of developing the horrible disease. The good news is that about 90% of colon cancer cases are preventable through a simple (yes, simple) colonoscopy.
Learn moreatom
Public service message from Business 2.0 Press